Ifo Institute chief Clemens Fuest calls for abolishing Germany's reduced VAT rate to close budget gaps, proposing targeted relief for low-income households instead
Executive summary: Clemens Fuest, head of the Ifo Institute, publicly advocated for abolishing Germany's reduced VAT rate of 7% to help close budget gaps, stating that all supermarket purchases could see higher taxes under such a reform. The proposal touches on core tensions in German fiscal policy between raising revenue efficiently and protecting low-income households from regressive tax effects, especially amid persistent budget pressures.
Who is involved: Key actors include Clemens Fuest (Ifo Institute), the German federal government (responsible for tax policy), and consumer households, particularly those with lower incomes who spend a larger share on VAT-taxed goods.
Likely next: The debate is expected to feed into upcoming coalition discussions on tax reform, with potential counter-proposals focusing on targeted subsidies or alternative revenue measures rather than broad VAT increases.
Clemens Fuest, president of the Ifo Institute, argues that eliminating Germany's reduced VAT rate (currently 7%) on goods like food could help plug fiscal shortfalls by broadening the tax base. He suggests that any resulting burden on consumers should be offset through targeted relief measures for vulnerable households rather than maintaining reduced rates. The proposal reflects ongoing debates about tax efficiency and equity in German fiscal policy, particularly as pressure mounts to address structural budget deficits without undermining social cohesion.
What's next — scenarios
Base Case: Fiscal Reform Stalemate (50%)
No immediate impact on consumer pricing or retail margins as political consensus remains absent.
- Coalition budget negotiations focus on spending cuts rather than tax restructuring
- Opposition parties reject VAT changes as regressive
Upside (Fiscal Aggression): VAT Harmonization (25%)
Increased tax revenue for the federal budget but significant upward pressure on food inflation and retail COGS.
- Government inclusion of VAT reform in the upcoming budget draft
- Introduction of a specific 'social compensation package' alongside tax hikes
Downside (Political Backlash): Inflationary Volatility (25%)
Erosion of consumer purchasing power if tax hikes are implemented without immediate, effective relief mechanisms.
- Public protests or major polling shifts regarding food affordability
- Failure of the government to define 'targeted relief' mechanisms
What to watch
- German Federal Ministry of Finance budget outlines (next 60 days)
- Public sentiment polls regarding food inflation and tax fairness (next 30 days)
- Official statements from coalition parties on VAT structure (next 90 days)
Timeline
- — Mehrwertsteuer: Ifo-Chef Clemens Fuest plädiert für Abschaffung des ermäßigten Satzes (Der Spiegel — Wirtschaft)
Analysis — what this means
Likely next events
- German coalition talks on tax reform expected by September 2026
- Ifo Institute to release detailed VAT reform impact analysis by October 2026
- Federal Ministry of Finance to evaluate targeted relief models for low-income households by Q4 2026
Sectors affected
- Food retail
- Public transportation
- Cultural services (e.g., theater tickets, museum entry)
- Local hospitality (hotels under 7% VAT)
Regulatory implications
- VAT Act (UStG) § 12 would require amendment to remove reduced rate categories
- Federal Ministry of Finance must assess social compensation mechanisms under EU VAT Directive rules
- Bundesrat approval needed for any VAT rate change, involving state governments
Historical parallels
- Germany’s 2007 VAT increase from 16% to 19% (standard) and 5% to 7% (reduced)
- France’s 2012–2014 debate on reducing restaurant VAT from 19.6% to 5.5% to boost employment
- Ireland’s 2009 temporary VAT reduction in hospitality sector during post-crisis recovery
Key entities
Sources
- Mehrwertsteuer: Ifo-Chef Clemens Fuest plädiert für Abschaffung des ermäßigten Satzes — Der Spiegel — Wirtschaft
Related cases
- Economist Peter Bofinger advocates for the abolition of the 'pension at 63' regulation in Germany
- SPD expert proposes five-year transition to abolish early retirement at 63, reflecting coalition tensions over pension reform
- DIW chief calls for ending Germany’s pension-at-63, intensifying coalition debate
- German artisan bakeries seek to lift the Sunday baking ban to compete with gas‑station bakeries